A recent press note by the Rajasthan State Tax Service Association, condemning Chartered Accountant (CA) Jatin Harjai’s remarks on alleged corruption in the GST department, has ignited a wave of support from tax professionals across the country.
In an emergency meeting held on September 12, 2024, the Association denounced the claims made by CA Harjai on social media, where he had accused GST officers of acting as “recovery agents” rather than upholding the law.
Despite the backlash from the GST officers and the passing of a resolution against Harjai, many members of the tax community, including chartered accountants and tax practitioners, have voiced their support for Harjai’s bold stance. They argue that his comments reflect genuine concerns shared by several professionals about the working of GST offices and their heavy-handed approach toward honest taxpayers.
In response to the Association’s demands for an apology and the deletion of the post, many tax professionals have rallied in defence of Harjai, highlighting that his statements merely bring to light the challenges faced by taxpayers and practitioners alike. These supporters emphasise that, rather than targeting the messenger, the system should focus on addressing corruption and the undue pressure on GST officers to meet recovery targets.
Several CA associations and tax bodies have expressed concern over the resolution passed by the Rajasthan Tax Service Association, which included a call to ban CA Harjai and other chartered accountants from participating as faculty in departmental training sessions. This, they argue, sets a dangerous precedent, stifling free expression and discouraging professionals from speaking out against systemic issues.
The intention behind CA Harjai’s comments was not to malign the entire department but to shed light on the issues faced by honest taxpayers and practitioners as tax professionals state, adding that these concerns need to be addressed constructively. Other professionals have warned that silencing criticism will only deepen the mistrust between taxpayers and the GST authorities.
As the controversy unfolds, it has sparked wider discussions about the state of affairs in GST enforcement, with tax practitioners calling for an open dialogue with the authorities to ensure that the concerns raised are adequately addressed rather than dismissed as baseless.
Support our journalism by subscribing to Taxscan premium. Follow us on Telegram for quick updates
